ACADEMIC COMPARISONS 2
How successful is Sycamore academically? Can it be quantified? If so, what are the measures? How are neighboring districts doing academically? How does Sycamore compare with all 613 traditional Ohio Public K-12 Schools? How does Ohio academic standards compare with other states? How does the U.S.A. success compare to other nations?
====================================================
Local high school sophomores who passed all five sections of the Ohio Graduation Test this year jumped nearly 10 percentage points from last year, according to preliminary results from the Ohio Department of Education.
. Ohio high school students must pass all sections of the test in order to graduate, though some exceptions can be made if the student passes four sections and meets other criteria. Kids get their first crack at it as sophomores. If they fail any section, they can retake it their junior and senior years and in some cases in the summer. Ohio students took the OGTs in March. The state’s results are preliminary.
. Just because a school district has a high percentage of sophomore sweeps doesn’t mean it’s better than others, experts say. The passage rate of sophomores is more closely tied to family income than how good a job the teachers are doing, according to Jack Jennings, president of the Center of Education Policy. The Washington-based group studies exit exams, including the OGT.
. In American education, the strongest factor is family background,” Jennings said. …….
About the test
. The Ohio Graduation Test replaced the Ninth-Grade Proficiency Test in 2004 and 2005 as the graduation requirement for high school students.
. It’s supposed to measure the expected level of skill in five subjects: reading, math, writing, science and social studies.
. Students get their first crack at the test their sophomore year. They can retake any section that they fail in their junior and senior years.
. OGT passage rates are important to school districts because they count toward THE DISTRICT’S Ohio Report Card, the overall rating of how districts are performing academically. The report card is generally considered a measure of how good a school district is.
. Nationally, 28 states require exit exams for high school students.
. Gov. Strickland signed legislation in 2009 to phase out OGT and replace it with a three-part graduation requirement that includes the ACT, end-of-course exams and a senior project.
. Jack Hennings from the Center on Education Policy says several states may revamp graduation requirements as they move toward national standard.
Source: More local sophomores pass test Number who pass Ohio gear exam up to 75%.
By Jessica Brown The Enquirer 6/25/11 C1
======================================
Mason City School District Named ‘Excellent’ for 11th Consecutive Year
Earns 5th Highest Score in State Academic Rankings, Meets AYP. For the eleventh year in a row, Mason City Schools earned an “Excellent” rating from the state of Ohio. The district scored a perfect 26 out of 26 indicators on this year’s Report Card. Mason City Schools have achieved a “perfect” score since the inception of the Ohio State Report Card in 2000-2001. The district is one of only seven other districts to achieve this honor continuously.
“It is impressive that Mason students consistently achieve at the highest levels on Ohio’s Report Card. We are equally proud that our students continue to excel in the arts, in athletics, in serving others, and in academic competitions. All of this is a tribute to their hard work, their supportive families, and their teachers’ commitment,” said Superintendent Kevin Bright. “We pledge to continue working with our community to elevate student learning to the highest possible levels, while keeping costs in check.”
Mason City Schools earned the fifth place spot out of 613 Ohio school districts for its performance index score. In fact, seven of the top performers are southwest Ohio districts. The performance index score measures a school district’s assessment results across all tested grades and all subjects based on the performance levels of untested, limited, basic, proficient, accelerated and advanced.
Ohio’s Academic Top 10 School Districts
| District Name(County) | Designation | Performance Index Score 2009-10 | Met AYP | Enrollment | Cost Per Pupil |
| Solon(Cuyahoga) | Excellent with Distinction | 110.5 | YES | 5,259 | $12,647 |
| Wyoming(Hamilton) | Excellent with Distinction | 110.4 | YES | 2,029 | $10,704 |
| Ottawa Hills(Lucas) | Excellent with Distinction | 110.1 | YES | 1,005 | $14,323 |
| Madeira(Hamilton) | Excellent | 109.7 | YES | 1,453 | $10,961 |
| Mason(Warren) | Excellent | 109.4 | YES | 10,637 | $10,528 |
| Indian Hill(Hamilton) | Excellent | 109.0 | YES | 2,107 | $14,770 |
| Oakwood(Montgomery) | Excellent with Distinction | 109.0 | YES | 2,192 | $10,361 |
| Mariemont(Hamilton) | Excellent with Distinction | 108.8 | YES | 1,669 | $12,592 |
| Hudson(Summit) | Excellent | 108.3 | YES | 5,056 | $12,740 |
| Sycamore(Hamilton) | Excellent with Distinction | 108.2 | YES | 5,502 | $13,522 |
Of Ohio’s top ten performers, Mason City Schools educate the most students. Additionally, Mason spends $1,786 less than the average Ohio Top 10 district.
Source: Mason School District web site as of 1/23/10
Success measures and data:
| 2007-2008 School Year Report Card | Performance Index % | Cost per Student | Measures of rigorous curriculum: | ||||
| Districts by Designation: Ohio Top 10 and some locals | Graduation Rate % | Mean ACT Score | Mean SAT Score | % of Grads with honors | % of Grads. With AP score of 3 or above | ||
| Excellent: top 10 | |||||||
| Ottawa | 109.7 | $8,525 | 100 | 26 | 1156 | 44 | 84 |
| Solon | 109.1 | $12,266 | 98.6 | 24 | 1120 | 43.4 | 100 |
| Wyoming | 109.0 | $10,734 | 100 | 26 | 1170 | 68.8 | 100 |
| Mason | 108.8 | $9,814 | 97.4 | 24 | 1118 | 35.3 | 55.6 |
| Indian Hill | 108.7 | $13,998 | 98.1 | 25 | 1136 | 43.3 | 100 |
| Miller | 108.2 | $9,856 | 95.2 | 25 | - | - | 100 |
| Chagrin | 108.1 | $10,875 | 100 | 26 | 1146 | 41.5 | 95.2 |
| Sycamore | 108.1 | $13,159 | 99.1 | 25 | 1128 | 61.4 | 89.1 |
| Oakwood | 107.8 | $9,974 | 98.8 | 26 | 1136 | 49.4 | 49.4 |
| Madeira | 107.6 | $10,688 | 95.4 | 25 | 1098 | 31.2 | 72.8 |
| Excellent: | |||||||
| Mariemont | 106.5 | $12,152 | 98.1 | 24 | 1110 | 36.3 | 36.3 |
| Kings | 105.0 | $9,723 | 95.5 | 24 | 1134 | 33.6 | 44.7 |
| Loveland | 104.8 | $9,320 | 97.5 | 23 | 1084 | 30.6 | 48.2 |
| Milford | 100.8 | $8,940 | 92.7 | 23 | 1102 | 15.9 | 31.2 |
| Effective: | |||||||
| Reading | 97.4 | 92 | 21 | 970 | 16.5 | 16 | |
| Continuous Improvement: | |||||||
| Cinti. | 81.9 | 80 | 19 | 944 | 12.2 | 29.5 | |
| Academic Watch: | |||||||
| Cleve. Muni. | 72.1 | 62 | 16 | 824 | 0 | 1.8 | |
| Academic Emergency: | |||||||
| None |
|
Performance Index* |
Designation |
Ohio Districts |
|
100 to 120 |
Excellent |
226 |
|
90 to 99.9 |
Effective |
293 |
|
0 to 89.9 |
Continuous Improvement |
83 |
|
70 to 79.9 |
Academic Watch |
9 |
|
0 to 69 |
Academic Emergency |
0 |
*Performance index is a measure of overall student achievement on the Ohio Achievement Test and Ohio Graduation Tests. A perfect score is 120. Ohio’s statewide score last year was 92.3.
Source: O.D.E.
Graduation Rate EMISMean ACT Score ACT Corp., EMIS
Percent of Graduates participating in the ACT ACT Corp., EMIS
Mean SAT Score College Board, EMIS
Percent of Graduates participating in the SAT College Board, EMIS
Percent of Graduates graduating with an Honors Diploma EMIS
Number of Graduates participating in an AP test College Board
Percent of Graduates with an AP score of 3 or above College Board
Number of Graduates taking at least one Tech Prep Course EMIS
Number of Graduates taking at least one PSEO course EMIS
Insights:
1. The performance index differences between the Ohio Top Ten are insignificant.
2. Our region accounts for 50% of the Ohio Top Ten districts – quite an accomplishment. And 30% of the Ohio Top Twenty, as Mariemont is included in that group.
3. Measures of rigorous curriculum are graduation rate, ACT, SAT, honor diplomas, and AP scores.
4. A hefty thirty seven percent of all Ohio districts are currently rated Excellent. This raises a question about the legitimacy of the rating itself.
5. The mean ACT and SAT scores and graduation rate seems to shows a clear difference between each of the five designation groups.
6. The Cincinnati Public School system, while in great need of improvement, is performing better than the Cleveland school system.
OTHER SUCCESS indicators:
MASON Class of 2008 [HS enrollment 2350]
_ 14 National Merit Scholarship finalists
_ 15 Commended Scholars
_ 1 National Achievement Scholar
_ 1 National Merit Achievement Program
_ 79 Cum Laude Graduates
_ 64 Magna Cum Laude Graduates
_ 254 Diploma with Honors Graduates
_ 3 National Technical Honors Society Graduates
_ 257 ‘Award of Merit’ Graduates
_ 80 Students receiving a four-year Academic Letter
_ Over 150 students receiv’d aca. &or ath. scholarships
_ Over $11,000,000.00 offered in scholarships and awards Source: Mason City School District –Departments–Public Information Office June 2008 Postcard
WYOMING 2008 [HS Enrollment 674]
National Merit Finalists _ 1
Commended – 8
National Merit Achievement Program – 0
Cum Laude – 33
Diploma with Honors – 81/155
Scholarships – 200 academic and 3 athletic
Estimate of dollars – $980, 000
Source: MK, Public Information Officer, February 09
MARIEMONT CLASS of 2008 [HS enrollment 505]
3_National Merit Scholarship finalists
4_Commended Scholars
na_ National Achievement Scholar
na_National Merit Achievement Program
22_ Cum Laude Graduates
na_Magna Cum Laude Graduates
48_ Diploma with Honors Graduates
na_National Technical Honors Society Graduates
50_‘Award of Merit’ Graduates
33_Students receiving a four-year Academic Letter
35_students received academic and/or athletic scholarships
$1,300,000,000.00 offered in scholarships and awards
Source: J.E. 12th Grade Counselor Feb., 2009
Click on EFFICIENCY COMPARISONS page
=====================================================================
How does the U.S.A. success compare to other nations?
The following are excerpts from a Guest Editorial found in
THE EDUCATION GADFLY
A Weekly Bulletin of News and Analysis from the Thomas B. Fordham Institute
Volume 9, Number 16. May 7, 2009.
International lessons about national standards
The 1997 release of the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) results was a wake-up call for the United States–and for Germany. But what’s notable about this particular event was not that both countries were outperformed by some 20 other nations or that the disappointing results spurred prolific and apocalyptic pontification on the dire implications and consequences on both sides of the Atlantic. What’s notable is how Berlin and Washington responded in drastically different ways.
The latest international test scores remind us that the U.S. still lags behind. Or,
Click on http://www.edexcellence.net/detail/news.cfm?news_id=736&id=
Then, Click Adobe PDF version (to read the actual report results)
By William H. Schmidt, Richard T. Houang, and Sharif M. Shakrani
William H. Schmidt is a University Distinguished Professor of Statistics and Education at Michigan State University and co director of the MSU Education Policy Center. Richard T. Houang is Adjunct Professor of Statistics and Education and Director of Research for the Center of Research on Mathematics and Science Education at MSU. Sharif M. Shakrani is Professor of Statistics and Education and co-director of the Education Policy Center, also at MSU. This editorial is drawn from a policy brief presented at Tuesday’s Fordham-sponsored conference, International Lessons about National Standards. Their full study will be available later this summer.
..About 28 percent of 2011 high school graduates in Ohio are ready for college – as measured by their passage rates on the ACT college entrance exam.
..Ohio students’ readiness rate was better than that of their peers nationwide, only 25 percent of whom are ready for college based on their test results.
..While they did better than the nation, Ohio students’ readiness rate remained flat from last year. Still, the state has gradually improved from 25 percent readiness in 2007.
.. Ohio Department of Education spokesman Patrick Gallaway said the state will continue to encourage “preparation at the local level” and will help districts as they adopt new curriculum standards this year.
..In Kentucky, 16 percent of 2011 graduates were ready for college; in Indiana, 31 percent. Those two states require all seniors to take the ACT (Ohio does not).
..The data was released today in the annual Condition of College and Career Readiness report. A student is considered academically “ready” if he met the test’s benchmarks in all four subjects: English, reading, math and science.
..The ACT is a national standardized achievement test that students take as juniors or seniors. The test is important – particularly for college-bound seniors – because colleges look at scores when considering a student’s application.
..Gallaway said the scores are a “barometer of what we need to do to prepare students to be college- and career-ready.”
..ACT benchmarks are the minimum score that a student needs to get on each subject test. Meeting a benchmark indicates that student would have a 50 percent chance of getting a B or a 75 percent chance of getting a C in specific first-year college courses –English composition, college algebra, introductory social science and biology – without the need for remediation.
..In all, 92,313 students, or 69 percent of 2011 Ohio graduates, took the ACT test last year, a 2.7 percent increase from 2010. The graduates posted an average composite score of 21.8 out of a possible 36.
..That’s better than Kentucky (19.6) but worse than Indiana (22.3). The national average is 21.1 percent.
..ACT does not release results for individual districts or schools, and districts are not required to report their scores to the Ohio Department of Education.
.. Nationally, college and career readiness increased 1 percentage point over last year, mostly due to students doing better in math and science.
..But 28 percent of the test-takers – 23 percent in Ohio – didn’t meet any benchmarks...Racial achievement gaps are also a problem.
..The vast majority of the test-takers in Ohio were white. Asian students did best on the tests, while African American students did the poorest.
..The gaps prompted criticism from the FairTest National Center for Fair & Open Testing.
..”Test-driven policies which claim to be improving U.S. Public Schools have, in fact, failed by their own standards,” said Director Bob Schaeffer. “Academic gains, as measured by ACT, are stagnant and racial gaps are increasing.”
About the ACT
What: The ACT is a national college admissions exam for high school juniors and seniors that consists of subject area tests in English, reading, math and science. Students can also opt to take a writing test. It includes 215 multiple-choice questions and takes approximately 3.5 hours to complete.
Cost: Registration fee is $34, although some school districts, including Cincinnati Public Schools, pay for their juniors to take the test.
Difference between the ACT and SAT: Act is an achievement test, measuring what a student has learned in school. The SDAT is more of an aptitude test, testing reasoning and verbal abilities.
Information: http://www.act.org.
Source: ww.act.org
Source: College-readiness rates beat national average By Jessica Brown, THE ENQUIRER 8/17/2011 B6
.. SAT reading scores for the high school class of 2011 were the lowest on record, and combined reading and math scores fell to their lowest point since 1995.
..The College Board, which released the scores, Wednesday, said the results reflect the record size and diversity of the pool of test-takers. As more students aim for college and take the exam, it tends to drag down average scores.
.. The Ohio reading score improved by one point. …math went down two points; reading stayed the same. ..in the context of the 800-point test, the national three-point decline in reading to 497 may seem little more than a blip; Average math scores for the class of 2011 fell one point to 514 and scores on critical reading section fell two points to 489.
.. The Ohio Department of Education noted that overall scores in Ohio remained above the national average, but the state still has work to do in improving college readiness.
Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana are among 44 states to adopt new Common Core Standards in English and math.
.. Bob Schaeffer, public education director of the group Fair Test, a longtime critic of the SAT, found unpersuasive the explanation that the declines were due largely due to a broadening test pool. In 2008, he said, the number of test takers expanded by a greater percentage than last year, but scores that year rose 6 points on math and reading.
.. Source: SAT reading scores decline to lowest ever By Justin Pope Associated Press, published in THE ENQUIRER 9/15/11 A6
. To find your school’s OAT (Ohio Achievement Test) passage rates, visit the Ohio Department of Education’s website at http://www.ode.state.oh.us. Click on “Testing” at the top of the page, then “Achievement Assessment”
. The Ohio Achievement Tests are state standardized tests for grades three through eight. Friday’s results are preliminary. They are expected to be finalized in August.
. The test results are important because they are among the measures used to determine a school or school district’s Ohio Report Card rating.
In addition to the OAT tests, the report cards also factor in Ohio Graduation Test scores, attendance rates, graduation rates and how much students improved during the course of the year.
. Source: Math thorny for many students. Local results vary greatly in early test results. By Jessica Brown The Enquirer 7/11/11 C1
To ADD
History gets D grade
Read page 210 of the SPECIAL INTEREST book. It covers two ways (ACT or SAT exams) student achievement is mostly measured. The math exams are taken by a small group of college bound students and therefore not a representative sample of most students. Math itself is only one of many subjects offered and by itself is not a wide measure of student performance.
Source: SPECIAL INTEREST book by author Terry M. Moe. Brookings Institution Copyright 2011, p210
27 area students named National Merit Scholars by Sue Kiesewetter Enquirer 5/4/2011 C3
Cincinnati Country Day
Mount Notre Dame
Mason
Summit Country Day
Oak Hills
Seven Hills
Sycamore
Mariemont
Springboro
Loveland
Cincinnati Hills Christian Academy
St. Ursula Academy
Lakota West
Indian Hill
——————————————
. Forty-three students from Greater Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky are among 1,700 National Merit Scholarship finalists who received between $ to $ annually for up to four years of undergraduate study.
. The awards were announced Monday. They are the last of the 2011 National MS winners. Other winners were named in three previous announcements.
. Anderson; Clark Montessori; Home School; Indian Hill; Kings; Lakota West; Mason; McNicholas; St. Ursula; St. Xavier; Seven Hills; Summit Country Day; Sycamore; Ursuline Academy; Walnut Hill and Wyoming.
. Overall, 8,300 students received awards. The students were selected from more than 1.5 million juniors from 22,000 high schools who took the 2009 Preliminary SAT/National Merit Scholarship Qualifying Test and made it to the finalist round.
. Source: 43 area students named Merit scholars. By Sue Kiesewetter The Enquirer 7/12/11 B3
“However, we do believe that the fiscal crisis, and the latest embarrassing rankings of U.S. students by the Program for International Student Assessment compared to their international peers (of 65 countries, American 15-year-olds were 17th in reading, 23rd in science, and 31st in math), can focus the nation on the need for change.
Source: “In Budget Crisis, an Opening for School Reform,” by Michelle Rhee, Wall Street Journal, January 11, 2011.
Opinion: Higher expectations, leaner rations
By Terry Ryan
Checker’s piece on the recent “Sputnik moment” for American education sent my mind reeling and my heart racing. According to the recent PISA findings, the U.S. is running in place educationally as other countries (e.g., China) accelerate improvements to their education systems. The United States faces becoming a second-class nation if we can’t figure out how to significantly lift student achievement. Having lived in Poland (one of the world’s fastest improving countries according to PISA data) for two and half years in the 1990s and being fortunate enough to travel to other parts of the world in the years since, I accept the reality that we are in a race with other countries to have the best educated and most innovative citizens in the world. The future will be dominated by the countries with the smartest people. As a parent of two young daughters, this fact both excites and scares me.
In Ohio, where I now live, lawmakers are girding themselves and their constituents for cuts of up to $8 billion out of a $50 billion state budget. As K-12 education comprises about 40 percent of that budget, it will face serious cuts in the next two years, with schools losing as much as 20 percent of the sums to which they’ve grown accustomed. Not only are we entering a new competitive global era but we’re doing so at a time of leaner rations. And not just in the Buckeye State.
This is no short-term challenge either. Education has to get dramatically better while it competes evermore fiercely for public dollars. In Ohio, for example, Medicaid spending now consumes about 26 percent of the state budget and enrollment trends look like a shuttle launch (see chart below). In 2008, for the first time in Ohio history, there were more enrollees in Medicaid than students in K-12 public schools.
There is also much justified concern about unfunded pension liabilities and the burden these are placing on state budgets. The PEW Center on the States documents a half trillion dollar gap between long-term liabilities and current funding levels. Ohio’s State Teachers Retirement System, for example, faces a $38.8 billion unfunded liability and the state’s four other public pension programs face similar chasms. But the challenge doesn’t stop there. By 2025, senior citizens are likely to outnumber the nation’s school age population for the first time in our history and, as James Guthrie and Arthur Peng point out in Stretching the School Dollar, “The U.S. needs to pay interest on and reduce its $13.7 trillion national debt; pay social security and fund the health-care needs of an aging population.”
Are you feeling the palpitations yet? Despite these serious challenges, I am optimistic about the future for the simple reason that a growing number of lawmakers, reformers, and innovators seems to genuinely understand that this our moment to tackle these challenges once and for all. As Sputnik showed, nothing focuses a nation’s energy like an existential threat to its future and that of its children. This is our time.
This piece originally appeared (in a slightly different format) on Fordham’s blog, Flypaper. 12/9/10
The U. S. News & Worlds Report of the top 100 public schools in the United States was recently published.
Walnut Hills ranked No. 65 and earned a gold medal from the magazine.
Wyoming received an honorable mention.
Kentucky’s Beechwood and Highlands earned silver medals.
Bronze medals were awarded to Clark Montessori, Fairfield, St.-Bernard, Ludow and Taft Information Technology High School.
To view the entire report, visit http://www.usnews.com/sectrions/education/high-schools
Source: Cinti. Enquirer 12/11/2009, Page B3. By Ben Fisher.
THE TOP ACADEMIC
OHIO HIGH SCHOOLS – 2009
NOVEMBER 19, 2009
PREPARED BY SCOTT GERBER
This document identifies the best schools in Ohio based on each school’s performance on the Ohio Graduation Test (OGT). This is the only report that examines Ohio’s public, private, and charter schools together. It analyzes the March 2009 OGT and it is an update to the versions that were available for the March 2007 and March 2008 tests.
For those unfamiliar with the OGT tests, there are five parts — Reading, Mathematics, Writing, Science, and Social Studies. There is also a summary page that shows the percentage of students who successfully passed all five parts with a “Proficient” rating. The data used in this report is from those five parts and from the summary.
There were 1,005 schools included in this analysis.
THE TOP ACADEMIC
OHIO HIGH SCHOOLS – 2009
19-Nov-09
Prepared By Scott Gerber
Ranking School
.
2 Cincinnati Country Day
3 Seven Hills
6 Ursuline
8 Walnut Hills
9 St. Xavier
17 Summit Country Day High
19 St. Ursula
35 McAuley
37 Indian Hill
39 Wyoming
46 Mariemont
51 McNicholas
56 Sycamore
57 Turpin
63 Mason
66 Madeira
71 Fenwick
73 Cinti Hills Christian
77 Moeller
93 Mother of Mercy
104 Elder
105 Anderson
106 LaSalle
111 Mount Notre Dame
http://gerberanalytics.com/data/data_top_schools/top_academic_ohio_2009_20091119.pdf
Wyoming is once again Ohio’s No. 1 school district, according to the state’s recently released (2008-2009) school report cards. Wyoming scored 110 points out of a possible 120.
Other highly-ranked Greater Cincinnati districts:
- Madeira (fourth, 109.5 points)
- Indian Hill (fifth, 109 points)
- Mason (sixth, 108.9 points)
- Mariemont (10th, 107.7 points)
Source: Cinti. Enquirer: September 6, 2009